In The News
CBS 58 Milwaukee
Shepherd Express
Featured Article: The Author and Story Behind The Sins We Inherit
Read full article: New Milwaukee Author Carlo Emanuele’s Debut Novel, ‘The Sins We Inherit’ - Shepherd Express
Shepherd Express Feature: Review
Experience Milwaukee Podcast
Visit Milwaukee - Joshing Around
Kirkus - Reviews
Critical Acclaim
Winner of the 2025 American Writing Award – Fiction
Carlo J. Emanuele’s debut novel, The Sins We Inherit, has been named the 2025 American Writing Award Category Winner for Fiction, a prestigious national honor recognizing outstanding storytelling, craft, and originality.
Selected from a highly competitive field of authors across the country, this award highlights the novel’s powerful blend of crime, family drama, and emotional depth. The Sins We Inherit follows Costantino “Cost” Caduto Jr. as he’s pulled back into Milwaukee’s criminal underworld while fighting to save what matters most—his daughter, his identity, and the last pieces of his soul.
This recognition places the novel at the forefront of emerging American fiction and positions it as a leading contender for film and television adaptation. As part of the award, The Sins We Inherit will be presented to literary agents, booksellers, libraries, and industry professionals nationwide.
“The Sins We Inherit is one of the year’s best thrillers.”
Finalist – BestThrillers.com 2025 Book Awards
The Sins We Inherit has been selected as a Finalist in the 2025 BestThrillers.com Book Awards, a major recognition within the thriller, crime, and suspense community. This honor highlights the novel’s rising momentum and its standout presence among this year’s most gripping works.
BestThrillers.com praised the novel, declaring:
“The Sins We Inherit is one of the year’s best thrillers.” — BestThrillers.com
Chosen from an exceptional field of submissions, this finalist placement underscores the power of Costantino “Cost” Caduto Jr.’s story—its raw emotional core, authentic underworld tension, and unforgettable character arcs. Set against the gritty landscape of Milwaukee’s criminal world, the novel blends high-stakes conflict with the intimate struggles of family, legacy, and survival.
This recognition further elevates The Sins We Inherit as a leading title in the genre and strengthens its positioning for film and television adaptation.
It joins a growing list of accolades, including the American Writing Award Category Winner for Fiction, solidifying the novel’s status as one of the most compelling crime dramas of the year.
"Powerful prose, unforgettable characters, & thematic depth"
Literary Titan - Gold Book Award Winner
The Sins We Inherit has been awarded the Literary Titan Gold Book Award — the organization’s highest honor. This award is reserved for books that achieve the top standard of excellence in storytelling, originality, and emotional impact.
Winning Gold places The Sins We Inherit among an elite group of works recognized for their powerful prose, unforgettable characters, and thematic depth.
What Literary Titan said
“Right from the opening pages … I felt pulled into the smoke-filled rooms and tight-lipped exchanges that define this world.”
“Emanuele balances the personal with the criminal. Cost isn’t just an heir to a mafia empire, he’s a divorced father trying to stay close to his daughter … The moment when she addresses him as ‘Dad’ … struck me with particular force.”
“What I didn’t expect was how much heart the book carries in its quieter moments … those scenes, where love and menace share the same table, give the book its punch.”
“The Sins We Inherit left me thoughtful and stirred. It’s not just a mob tale, it’s a story about trying to be better for the people you love, even when the past won’t let you.”
Indies Today
Indies Today Book Awards — 2026 Runner-Up (Suspense)
National recognition for excellence in independent crime fiction and suspense storytelling
The Sins We Inherit was named a Runner-Up in the Suspense category at the 2026 Indies Today Book Awards — a recognition that highlights standout independent novels resonating with readers and critics alike. Known for celebrating bold storytelling and emerging voices in modern fiction, Indies Today honors books that combine strong narrative craft with emotional impact. This recognition adds to the growing acclaim surrounding Carlo J. Emanuele’s gritty Milwaukee-set crime drama, further establishing the series as a rising voice in contemporary suspense.
"A compelling yarn filled w/ drama, crime, and identity"
Kirkus - 'A compelling yarn filled with drama, crime, and contemplations of identity'
In Emanuele’s thriller, the estranged grandson of a Mafia boss is lured back into a life of crime after his grandfather’s death.
The story opens in Milwaukee during the wake of Costantino “Cost” Caduto’s grandfather, Tiger, who had maintained a dominant presence in the construction business and in organized crime.
His grandson has distanced himself from this milieu to raise his daughter, Maddy, after a fractured marriage. Tiger’s funeral brings Cost back into the center of Milwaukee’s criminal world, and Cost’s eulogy (“Tiger didn’t just live in this city. He helped shape it”) leads some to believe he might be ready to follow in his grandfather’s footsteps, igniting old rivalries. Frank Vistoso, who thinks he’s Tiger’s rightful heir, bristles at Cost’s presence, and biker-gang leader Marek Novak sets his sights on the Caduto family. Cost tries to protect Maddy and Maria Celestina, a lost love from his past, with whom he’s reconnecting.
As the narrative unfolds, often via family gatherings, Cost’s confrontations with Frank and his circle escalate. Cost realizes that despite his attempts to stay out of the “family business,” allies such as Donny Caduto and Lorenzo Leale are looking to him for leadership. Attorney James Flut, who was loyal to Tiger, is now assessing how the crime enterprise can survive. Cost struggles to choose between embracing his legacy or rewriting the story of his bloodline. Emanuele’s novel, set in a crime-ridden world, combines harsh elements with poetic language and explores how subtle interactions can expose feelings of loyalty and fear. Cost displays strong character development as he reckons with past wounds and his desperate wish to create a better life for his daughter.
The story increases in danger and emotional impact via the well-developed characters of Frank, who displays fake confidence, and Maddy, who keeps her feelings hidden. The narrative’s deliberate pacing sets a rhythm that matches the heavy burden Cost bears in his situation.
A compelling yarn filled with drama, crime, and contemplations of identity.
5 Stars - "Underneath the gunmetal, there’s a father’s love"
Literary Titan - Rating: 5 Stars
Carlo J. Emanuele’s The Sins We Inherit is a bruising, heartfelt story about family, legacy, and the ways the past refuses to stay buried. The novel follows Costantino “Cost” Caduto II as he returns to his family’s orbit after the death of his grandfather, Tiger, a man whose shadow looms over Milwaukee’s underworld and over Cost’s own conflicted heart. The book moves through wakes, eulogies, burials, backyard feasts, and street confrontations, blending the intimacy of family drama with the sharp edges of a crime saga. It’s about fathers and daughters, fathers and sons, and the ways love can be messy, protective, and even dangerous.
Right from the opening pages, where Cost stands at Tiger’s wake, worn down and haunted, I felt pulled into the smoke-filled rooms and tight-lipped exchanges that define this world. The writing is cinematic without being overstuffed; little details like the smell of cigar smoke or the scrape of pews in a church make the world feel alive. At times, though, the heaviness of description slows things down, especially in the funeral chapters, but I didn’t mind lingering there. It felt true to the weight of grief, and it set the stage for the power struggles that follow.
I also appreciated how Emanuele balances the personal with the criminal. Cost isn’t just an heir to a mafia empire, he’s a divorced father trying to stay close to his daughter, Maddy, even as she slips through his fingers. The moment when she addresses him as “Dad” at the wake, only to retreat into the crowd, struck me with particular force. That small interaction captured more distance and heartbreak than any shouting match could. Later, when Frank Vistoso tries to assert himself at the altar during Tiger’s funeral, it’s not just a clash of egos; it’s a reminder that Cost can never fully escape this world, no matter how much he wants to. I found myself rooting for him, even when I suspected he wouldn’t get the peace he craved.
What I didn’t expect was how much heart the book carries in its quieter moments. A favorite scene of mine was the repast after the funeral, with sausage sizzling on the grill and cousins arguing over poker. The food, the noise, the laughter, it all felt warm and familiar, and it reminded me that this story isn’t only about violence and legacy, but also about belonging. I could almost smell the garlic bread and hear Sinatra crackling on the speaker. It’s those scenes, where love and menace share the same table, that give the book its punch.
The Sins We Inherit left me thoughtful and stirred. It’s not just a mob tale, it’s a story about trying to be better for the people you love, even when the past won’t let you. I’d recommend this book to readers who enjoy crime dramas with a human center, especially fans of The Sopranos or Dennis Lehane. But I’d also recommend it to anyone who’s ever wrestled with family expectations, or who’s wondered how much of our lives are chosen versus inherited. It’s a dark, gripping read, but underneath the gunmetal, there’s a father’s love beating strong.
Thank you,
Priscilla Evans
Managing Editor
Literary Titan
WEAR THE STORY - Two worlds. One legacy.
INHERITED — built, not given.
THE SINS WE INHERIT | Collector’s Series
THE SINS WE INHERIT | Collector’s Series
This is not merch.
This is identity.
Every piece in the INHERITED collection is designed as a subtle statement — clean, elevated, and intentionally minimal.
Whether you wear it to the gym, on the street, or out with friends, it’s about who you are, not what you advertise.
This collection is for:
• The ones who build in silence
• Those who hold themselves to a higher standard
• People who choose depth over noise
Explore pieces that stand for something deeper.
Because what you inherit is a foundation — what you build defines you.
THE SINS WE INHERIT | Collector’s Series
THE SINS WE INHERIT | Collector’s Series
THE SINS WE INHERIT | Collector’s Series
Wear the world you stepped into.
Inspired directly by the novel The Sins We Inherit, this series connects you to the story — not as a fan, but as part of the narrative.
Here, quotes and imagery come from the themes of legacy, family, power, and consequence.
This collection is for those who resonated with the book — not because it was a story…
but because it felt like part of their own.
About the author
Carlo J. Emanuele discovered the power of storytelling not through triumph, but through heartbreak.
Writing became his lifeline—a way to make sense of anxiety, grief, and the quiet storms that reshaped his life. What began as late-night journal entries soon gave rise to a voice, a character, and eventually a world. That world became The Sins We Inherit.
Born and raised on Milwauee’s South Side in a tight-knit Italian American family, Carlo was shaped by the quiet strength of the men around him. Their stories—often unspoken, but deeply felt—left a lasting impression. Loyalty, resilience, and complexity became the emotional foundation of his debut novel.
But The Sins We Inherit is also deeply personal. It was born from a period of emotional reckoning. A relationship—intense, transformative—became a catalyst for his writing. While the story is fictional, the emotions are real: longing, loss, hope. Writing became a way to process pain, honor a connection that changed him, and ultimately, find a path forward.
Before becoming an author, Carlo played collegiate basketball at Carroll University and built a successful corporate career with organizations like Direct Supply and Brady Corporation. But behind every professional milestone was a man still searching for meaning and connection.
The Sins We Inherit is more than a crime drama—it’s a reckoning. A story about generational weight, the fight for redemption, and the cost of staying loyal to the people and places that shape us.
Carlo is a proud father of two daughters, whose strength and love remain the heart of his journey. His writing is rooted in truth, family, and the pursuit of healing. The Sins We Inherit is just the beginning—more stories are coming, stories that explore the fragility and fire inside all of us.
“I didn’t set out to write a novel. I set out to survive the nights that wouldn’t let me sleep. Somewhere along the way, a story found me.”
—Carlo J. Emanuele
Follow Carlo's journey and stay connected through social media: Facebook / Discover The Sins We Inherit - A New Underworld Book
Bookstore & Library Orders
🛒 How to Order Wholesale Copies
The Sins We Inherit is available via Ingram Book Group. Bookstores and libraries can order using the following details:
Title / Author / Publisher
- Title: The Sins We Inherit
- Author: Carlo J. Emanuele
- Publisher: Verde Entertainment, LLC
ISBN's
- Paperback: 979-8-9992754-1-7
- Hardcover: 979-8-9992754-2-4
Specifications
- Trim Size: 6 x 9 inches
- Pages: 260
- Genre: Crime Fiction / Suspense / Family Drama
- Discount: Standard Wholesale Discount
📢 Media & Events
Interested in hosting a signing, stocking the book, or featuring it at your store? I’d love to collaborate.